EPLI Insurance for Churches in Pennsylvania: Employment Practices Liability Coverage

Affiliate disclosure: Dareable earns a commission when you purchase coverage through links on this page. This does not affect our recommendations.

Pennsylvania churches face a layered employment law environment that creates EPLI exposure at different levels depending on location and employer size. The Pennsylvania Human Relations Act applies to employers with four or more employees and prohibits discrimination based on race, color, religious creed, ancestry, age, sex, national origin, and disability. In Philadelphia, the Fair Practices Ordinance applies to employers with one or more employees within city limits, covering the same classes as PHRA with additional protections. The ministerial exception established in Hosanna-Tabor and expanded in Our Lady of Guadalupe protects Pennsylvania churches' employment decisions about pastors, worship leaders, and religious educators. Non-ministerial staff, including office personnel, custodians, childcare workers, and support staff, have the full protection of PHRA and, for Philadelphia-based churches, the FPO from the first hire. Pennsylvania's mandatory reporting law, often called Childline, requires any person who suspects child abuse to make a report to the Department of Human Services ChildLine and Abuse Registry, and church employees who work with children are specifically subject to this obligation. Adverse action against an employee who made a good-faith Childline report creates EPLI exposure that churches must be prepared to defend. EPLI insurance covers non-ministerial employment claims and pays the legal cost of establishing ministerial status when a role's classification is challenged.

Embroker places EPLI for Pennsylvania faith-based organizations and understands how PHRA's four-employee threshold and Philadelphia's one-employee FPO create different coverage needs for churches across the state.

Quick Answer: What Does EPLI Insurance Cost for Churches in Pennsylvania?

Congregation Size	Annual Premium Range
Small congregation, 1 to 10 employees	$1,500 to $3,500
Mid-size, 10 to 50 employees	$3,500 to $8,500
Large congregation, 50 to 200 employees	$8,500 to $22,000
Multi-site / megachurch	$22,000 to $55,000+

Pennsylvania premiums reflect the four-employee PHRA threshold statewide and the one-employee FPO threshold in Philadelphia. Philadelphia churches pay higher premiums due to the FPO's any-size coverage and its expanded protected classes. Prior claims, active childcare programs, and high non-ministerial staff turnover increase premiums across the state.

What EPLI Insurance Covers for Churches

Wrongful Termination of Non-Ministerial Staff

Under PHRA, any Pennsylvania employer with four or more employees may not discharge a non-ministerial employee based on a protected characteristic. A church administrative coordinator terminated after requesting pregnancy leave has a plausible sex discrimination claim under PHRA. A facilities worker terminated after disclosing a disability has a potential disability discrimination claim. EPLI covers the cost of defending those claims through the Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission investigation process and any subsequent civil litigation in state or federal court.

The ministerial exception applies in Pennsylvania courts following the Hosanna-Tabor and Our Lady of Guadalupe standards. The Third Circuit, which covers Pennsylvania, has applied the ministerial exception to roles that involve religious leadership, teaching of doctrine, and performance of religious rituals. Roles clearly outside that definition, including receptionists, bookkeepers, and custodians, are non-ministerial regardless of their religious organizational context. Contested roles in youth ministry, religious education administration, and counseling frequently require litigation to resolve. EPLI covers those legal costs.

Harassment Claims from Staff and Congregation Members

PHRA prohibits hostile work environment harassment based on protected class characteristics at four employees. For Philadelphia churches, FPO applies at any size. Harassment claims against Pennsylvania churches typically involve non-ministerial supervisors creating hostile conditions for non-ministerial subordinates, or ministerial staff engaging in conduct toward non-ministerial employees that crosses into legal harassment territory. EPLI covers defense costs through the Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission and Philadelphia Commission on Human Relations processes and any subsequent civil litigation.

Philadelphia's Fair Practices Ordinance includes protections not found in PHRA, such as protections based on domestic or sexual violence victim status and other city-specific categories. Churches with Philadelphia-based non-ministerial staff need EPLI that explicitly covers FPO-based harassment claims.

Discrimination in Hiring Non-Ministerial Roles

At four or more employees statewide, and at any size in Philadelphia, churches face discrimination exposure for non-ministerial hiring decisions. A church that declines to hire a qualified bookkeeper because of that person's age, ancestry, or disability faces a PHRA claim. Philadelphia churches that decline to hire based on protected categories covered by FPO but not PHRA face FPO exposure. EPLI covers the legal defense costs and settlements for discrimination charges filed with the PHRC, Philadelphia CHR, or EEOC.

Retaliation for Reporting Child Safety or Misconduct Concerns

Pennsylvania's mandatory reporting law requires any person who has reasonable cause to suspect child abuse to make a report to ChildLine, the state's central registry maintained by the Department of Human Services. Church employees who work with children are mandated reporters under Pennsylvania law, and the law explicitly prohibits retaliation against employees who make good-faith reports. A childcare worker or youth program coordinator at a Pennsylvania church who reports suspected abuse and is subsequently terminated or disciplined has a strong retaliation claim. EPLI covers the full defense cost of those claims. Pennsylvania courts and juries take child safety retaliation seriously, and the defense cost can be substantial even when the church's position is legally sound.

Pennsylvania Employment Law: What Churches Must Know

The Pennsylvania Human Relations Act is enforced by the Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission, which investigates charges and conducts hearings. PHRC has a one-year complaint period from the date of the alleged violation. Cases where probable cause is found can proceed to the PHRC hearing process or, after 90 days, to civil court. PHRA's four-employee threshold makes it applicable to most Pennsylvania churches with any non-ministerial staff.

The Philadelphia Fair Practices Ordinance, enforced by the Philadelphia Commission on Human Relations, applies to any employer operating within Philadelphia with one or more employees. For churches with any paid non-ministerial staff in Philadelphia, FPO coverage is immediate. Philadelphia's expanded protected classes, enforcement resources, and generally plaintiff-friendly legal environment create a higher risk profile for Philadelphia-area churches than for those in other parts of the state.

Pennsylvania's Childline mandatory reporting system is one of the most developed in the country. Mandatory reporters are required to make both an immediate oral report and a written report within 48 hours. Church employees who work with children, including those in daycare programs, Sunday school, and youth ministries, are covered reporters. Pennsylvania law makes retaliation against mandated reporters explicitly unlawful. EPLI covers the cost of defending retaliation claims by church employees who allege adverse action after making a Childline report.

Pennsylvania does not currently have a state-level pay transparency law equivalent to California's SB 1162. PHRA's anti-discrimination provisions still prohibit pay disparities based on protected characteristics for non-ministerial employees. Churches should maintain pay equity across demographic groups within non-ministerial roles to reduce downstream EPLI exposure.

Frequently Asked Questions

Our Pennsylvania church has 6 employees, three of whom are ministerial. Does PHRA apply to our non-ministerial staff?

Yes. PHRA applies to employers with four or more employees. Your total employee count, which is 6, determines whether the threshold is met. The ministerial exception protects your employment decisions about the three ministerial employees, but your three non-ministerial employees can bring PHRA discrimination, harassment, and retaliation claims. EPLI covers the cost of defending those claims.

Our church is in Philadelphia with two paid non-ministerial employees. What law applies?

The Philadelphia Fair Practices Ordinance applies to any employer in Philadelphia with one or more employees. With two non-ministerial employees, your church is fully subject to FPO regardless of whether it meets PHRA's four-employee statewide threshold. The FPO covers the same basic protected classes as PHRA plus additional Philadelphia-specific categories. EPLI for Philadelphia churches should explicitly cover FPO-based claims. The Philadelphia Commission on Human Relations enforces the FPO.

What is Childline and how does it create EPLI risk for our church?

Childline is Pennsylvania's mandatory child abuse reporting registry, maintained by the Department of Human Services. Any person who has reasonable cause to suspect child abuse must call ChildLine (1-800-932-0313) and file a written report within 48 hours. Church employees and volunteers who work with children are mandated reporters. If your church takes any adverse action against an employee after they made a Childline report, that person has a retaliation claim under Pennsylvania law. EPLI covers the defense costs from the moment the claim is filed.

Does EPLI cover the cost of arguing that a contested role is ministerial in Pennsylvania?

Yes. When a non-ministerial employment claim is filed against your church and the church's defense includes an argument that the claimant's role actually qualifies as ministerial under the First Amendment, EPLI covers the legal fees for making that argument. The court applies the Hosanna-Tabor four-factor test and the Our Lady of Guadalupe functional analysis to determine whether the exception applies. That legal process can take months and cost tens of thousands of dollars regardless of the outcome. EPLI funds that defense from start to finish.

---

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or insurance advice. Consult a licensed insurance professional for guidance specific to your business.